Routine removal of the carotid sheath as part of neck dissection is unnecessary if grossly uninvolved as seen intra-operatively

Abstract

The aim of this research was to determine the pathologic invasion of the carotid sheath (CS) when found grossly uninvolved during surgery, in patients undergoing neck dissection for head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC). A prospective study was undertaken in 70 consecutive patients with biopsy proven HNSCC, without prior history of any treatment, undergoing neck dissection, in whom the CS was found grossly uninvolved intra-operatively, were included. A total of 80 neck dissections were performed. Supra-omohyoid neck dissections for clinically N0 neck and appropriate modified radical neck dissections for clinically N+ neck were carried out. 129 CS were dissected separately and thoroughly examined by well trained head and neck pathologists for tumour infiltration and the presence of lymphatic tissue. On microscopic examination, 27 patients were N0 status and the remaining 43 (61.4%) had at least one metastatic lymph node (N+). None of 129 CS specimens show the presence of normal lymphatic tissue or metastatic tumour deposits. The authors think that avoiding resection of the CS in the absence of gross invasion by nodal disease is possible without jeopardising oncologic safety. A preserved CS might offer protection to the important neurovascular structures and reduce significant morbidity.