Root Cause Failure Analysis of Deep-Groove Ball Bearing Used in a Governor

Abstract

Premature failure of a deep-groove ball bearing used in an aeroengine governor took place during service. In this paper, the failure mode and root cause of the bearing were studied by macroscopic and microscopic examination, metallographic analysis, hardness test, calculations of contact stress and L10 life, flatness measurement and comparative experiment. The results show that the failure modes of the inner ring raceway and steel balls are contact fatigue spalling, the failure modes of the outer ring raceway are wear and contact fatigue spalling, and the failure mode of the cage is fatigue fracture. The root cause and direct cause of the bearing failure were the unqualified machining process of the spring end face and the high unbalanced axial load, respectively. The unqualified machining process induced high points of the spring end face, which caused misalignment of the outer ring and inner ring and thereby resulted in the high unbalanced axial load. The characteristic damages induced by high axial load were climbing with the morphology of metal extrusion and accumulation at the border of the raceway for the inner and outer ring, and multiple fatigue fractures with the characteristic of multi origins for the cage. The unqualified machining process can be prevented by adopting the refined grinding process and adding detection requirements of flatness.