RNA 3-dimensional structural motifs as a critical constraint of viroid RNA evolution.

Abstract

Viroids are circular noncoding RNAs infecting plants [1, 2]. During infection, viroids, like RNA viruses, generate swarms of sequence variants called quasispecies [3, 4]. Viroids in Avsunviroidae family replicate in chloroplasts and display the highest mutation rates among all living entities [5]. Viroids in Pospiviroidae family replicate in the nucleus with a relatively lower mutation rate resembling some RNA viruses [6]. Those sequence variants generated during replication are described by the concept of sequence space, which harnesses a geometric representation to illustrate genetic similarities via physical distances. Given the high mutation rate and fast propagation, viroid RNAs have a potentially large sequence space for the evolution of new variants. However, in reality, they use only a small fraction of this space. Constraints of viral sequence space may include genome size, replication fidelity, error thresholds, host or tissue tropism, etc. These factors have been nicely reviewed elsewhere [3, 7, 8] and are not the focus of this Pearl. In addition, RNA secondary structures have been considered, though not adequately, as a constraint factor [8]. Viroids, in contrast to viruses, entirely rely on their RNA structural motifs for function due to their noncoding nature, which offers insights into their capacity to explore regions of sequence space influenced by RNA structures. Here, we describe that 3-dimensional (3D) structural motifs formed by non–Watson-Crick (non-WC) base pairs in viroid RNAs act as a critical constraint for the sequence space of viroid genome evolution. This constraint operates because RNA 3D motifs can play crucial roles by mediating (1) RNA–RNA interactions for the folding of a part or a whole of RNA into a distinct tertiary conformation and (2) RNA–protein interactions. Therefore, mutations in a 3D motif that do not disrupt the structure and function will be retained in the population, whereas mutations that disrupt the 3D structures of motifs, and consequently the function, will be lost.