River flow and ammonium discharge determine spring phytoplankton blooms in an urbanized estuary

Abstract

Nutrient loadings to urbanized estuaries have increased over the past decades in response to population growth and upgrading to secondary sewage treatment. Evidence from the San Francisco Estuary (SFE) indicates that increased ammonium (NH4) loads have resulted in reduced primary production, a counter-intuitive finding; the NH4 paradox. Phytoplankton uptake of nitrate (NO3), the largest pool of dissolved inorganic nitrogen, is necessary for blooms to occur in SFE. The relatively small pool of ambient NH4, by itself insufficient to support a bloom, prevents access to NO3 and bloom development. This has contributed to the current rarity of spring phytoplankton blooms in the northern SFE (Suisun Bay), in spite of high inorganic nutrient concentrations, improved water transparency and seasonally low biomass of bivalve grazers. The lack of blooms has likely contributed to deleterious bottom-up impacts on estuarine fish. This bloom suppression may also occur in other estuaries that receive large amounts of anthropogenic NH4. In 2010 two rare diatom blooms were observed in spring in Suisun Bay (followed by increased abundances of copepods and pelagic fish), and like the prior bloom observed in 2000, chlorophyll accumulated after NH4 concentrations were decreased. In 2010, low NH4 concentrations were apparently due to a combination of reduced NH4 discharge from a wastewater treatment plant and increased river flow. To understand the interactions of river flow, NH4 discharge and bloom initiation, a conceptual model was constructed with three criteria; 1) NH4 loading must not exceed the capacity of the phytoplankton to assimilate the inflow of NH4, 2) the NH4 concentration must be ≤4 μmol L−1 to enable phytoplankton NO3 uptake, 3) the dilution rate of phytoplankton biomass set by river flow must not exceed the phytoplankton growth rate to avoid “washout”. These criteria were determined for Suisun Bay; with sufficient irradiance and present day discharge of 15 tons NH4–N d−1at the upstream wastewater treatment plant (WTP). The loading criterion requires phytoplankton NH4 uptake to exceed 1.58 mmol m−2 d−1; the concentration criterion requires river flow >800 m3 s−1 at the WTP for sufficient NH4 dilution and the washout criterion requires river flow at Suisun Bay <1100 m3 s−1. The model and criteria are used to suggest how a reduction in anthropogenic NH4, either by reduced discharge or increased dilution (river flow), could be used as a management tool to restore pre-existing productivity in the SFE and similarly impacted estuaries.