Risk Premium and Fear of Investors in Crisis’ Periods: An Empirical Approach Based on Fama–French and Carhart Factor Models

Abstract

This study aims to answer the question about the interactions between “investors’ fear”, two factors proposed by Fama & French, the Carhart momentum factor, andthe risk premium, and how these interactions were affected by two financial crises, the Dot-Com and Sub-Prime crises. This paper is the first empirical study that considers the effects of these financial crises. It is of critical importance as it changes the specificity of the empirical models for different periods, significantly affecting the results compared to previous research work. The main findings include a general negative change in fear over all of the sub-periods. Secondly, no consistent positive trend was observed in any of the risk premiums over time. After each crisis, the relationships between the endogenous variables had significant changes. More specifically, investors’ fear, on the first day of the week, appears to be systematically higher across all sub-periods except during the Sub-Prime crisis. Finally, after the Sub-Prime financial crisis, there is an almost complete loss of the explanatory power of the VAR models. Although fear does not seem to affect risk premiums or momentum, it was nevertheless found that the results are sensitive to the specification of the models.