Risk of tumor induction in vivo by residual cellular DNA: Quantitative considerations

Abstract

Certain genes, termed oncogenes, have the ability to transmit the transformed phenotype from tumor cells to hitherto normal cells in vitro and in vivo. This observation is the basis for the concern that medicinal products derived from tumor cell lines could contain possibly tumorigenic contaminating cellular DNA. A comparison between the number of oncogenes necessary for the induction of tumors in a suitable animal model and the quantity in 100 pg residual cellular DNA was carried out. It is shown that the latter contains less than a billionth of the number needed to induce tumors in half of the animals tested. Some factors implicit to this calculation such as the validity of the model system, the linearity of the dose response curve, the concept of multistep carcinogenesis, the amplification of oncogenes, and the transfection enhancing effect of other constituents of the drug are discussed. In summary, 100 pg residual cellular DNA per dose seems to be a safe and, therefore, an acceptable upper limit provided that some factors such as excessive amplification of oncogenes, co-purification of oncogenic DNA with the product or some transfection mediating activity can be excluded.