Risk management or racial Bias? The disparate use of restraints in the Emergency Department of an Urban Safety-Net Hospital

Abstract

ObjectivesLimited data exist on racial-ethnic differences in the application of restraints for patients visitng the emergency department (ED). This study examines whether there is an association between race and patient ED visit type with the application of four-point mechanical restraints in a high acuity safety-net urban academic hospital. MethodsThe study retrospectively reviewed 198,610 visits to the ED at Boston Medical Center made by patients between 18 and 89 years old between May 1, 2014 and May 1, 2019. ED visit type was categorized based on primary billing code for the visit as either medical or behavioral; behavioral visits were further categorized into 5 groups based on corresponding primary psychiatric billing code category. The relationships between race/ethnicity and four-point mechanical restraints were analyzed using binary logistic regression models in SPSS. Results1.4% of unique visits involved the use of four-point mechanical restraints. Patients with a behavioral visit were significantly over 16 times more likely to be restrained than those with a medical visit. Black patients were significantly more likely to be restrained than white patients for behavioral visits but less likely for medical visits. Black and Hispanic patients were also significantly more likely to be restrained for a behavioral visit regardless of psychiatric diagnosis. Asian patients were less likely to be restrained regardless of ED visit type. ConclusionsSignificant racial differences in restraints for White patients with medical visits and Black and Hispanic patients with behavioral visits prompts further investigation on the role of clinician bias when managing acute patients.