Revolutionizing Liver Transplantation: Transitioning to an Elective Procedure via ex situ Normothermic Machine Perfusion - A Benefit Analysis.

Abstract

To assess the impact of Normothermic Machine Perfusion (NMP) on patients, medical teams, and costs by gathering global insights and exploring current limitations. NMP for ex-situ liver graft perfusion is gaining increasing attention for its capability to extend graft preservation. It has the potential to transform liver transplantation (LT) from an urgent to a pure elective procedure, which could revolutionize LT logistics, reduce burden on patients and healthcare providers, and decrease costs. A 31-item survey was sent to international transplant directors to gather their NMP experiences and vision. Additionally, we performed a systematic review on cost-analysis in LT and assessed studies on cost-benefit in converting urgent-to-elective procedures. We compared the costs of available NMPs and conducted a sensitivity analysis on NMP's cost benefits. Of 120 transplant programs contacted, 64 (53%) responded, spanning North America (31%), Europe (42%), Asia (22%), and South America (5%). Sixty percent had adopted NMP, with larger centers (>100 transplants/year) in North America and Europe more likely to use it. Main NMP systems were OrganOx-metra (39%), XVIVO (36%), and TransMedics-OCS (15%). Despite NMP adoption, 41% of centers still perform >50% of LTs at nights/weekends. Centers recognized NMP's benefits, including improved work satisfaction and patient outcomes, but faced challenges like high costs and machine complexity. 16% would invest $100'000-500'000, 33% $50'000-100'000, 38% $10'000-50'000, and 14% <$10'000 in NMP. These results were strengthened by a cost analysis for NMP in emergency-to-elective LT transition. Accordingly, while liver perfusions with disposables up to $10'000 resulted in overall positive net balances, this effect was lost when disposables' cost amounted to >$40'000/organ. The adoption of NMP is hindered by high costs and operational complexity. Making LT elective through NMP could reduce costs and improve outcomes, but overcoming barriers requires national reimbursements and simplified, automated NMP systems for multi-day preservation.