Revisiting the allometry of antlers among deer species: male–male sexual competition as a driver

Abstract

The positive allometry between antlers and shoulder height reported for cervids has previously been interpreted as resulting from a high male‐male competition in large species that form large breeding groups. We aim at revisiting relative antler size variation among deer species by including more species (n = 31) and by testing both direct and indirect influences of different sexual selection proxies on the relative antler length using path analysis. The absence of direct effect of mating tactic on relative antler allometry indicates that the strength of fights does not differ among mating tactics. On the other hand, the main effect of breeding group size is revealed by polygyny. Highly polygynous species have relatively longer antlers than less polygynous ones but the difference in the relative effect of breeding group size on relative antler length is weak. Strong direct effect of breeding group size and indirect effect of mating tactic shaped the observed variation in the relative antler size among deer, suggesting that the amount of male‐male competition is the main evolutionary force of antler allometry in cervids.