Review of “Environmental and hydrologic controls on sediment and organic carbon export from a subalpine catchment: insights from a time-series” by Melissa Schwab and co-authors

Abstract

Studies engaging in tracking headwater carbon signatures downstream remain sparse, despite their importance for constraining transfer and transformation pathways of organic carbon (OC) and developing regional-scale perspectives on mechanisms influencing the balance between remineralization and carbon export. Based on a 40-month time series, we investigate the dependence of hydrology and seasonality on the discharge of sediment and OC in a small Swiss subalpine watershed (Sihl River basin). We analyze concentrations and isotopic compositions (δ13C, F14C) of particulate OC and use dual-isotope mixing and machine learning frameworks to characterize and estimate source contributions, transport pathways, and export fluxes. The majority of transferred OC is sourced from plant biomass and soil material. Relative proportions of soil-derived particulate OC peak during the summer months, coinciding with maximum soil erosion rates. Bedrock-derived (petrogenic) OC abundant in headwater streams progressively decreases downstream in response to a lack of source material and efficient overprinting with biospheric organic matter, illustrating rapid OC transformation over short distances. Large variations in isotopic compositions observed during baseflow conditions converge and form a homogenous mixture enriched in OC and characterized by higher POC- F14C values following precipitation-driven events. We propose that storms facilitate surface runoff and shallow landsliding, resulting in the entrainment of fresh litter and surficial soil layers. Model results further indicate diverging mobilization pathways. Discharge and water stage describe the export of suspended sediment, while the prediction of POC fluxes is mostly supported by water stage and 1-day antecedent precipitation. Although particle transport in the Sihl River basin is mainly driven by hydrology, subtle changes in bedrock erosivity, slope angle, and floodplain extent likely have profound effects on the POC composition, age, and export yields.