Retrospective study on the efficacy of different chemotherapy regimens concurrently combined with intensity modulated radiation therapyin treatment of Ⅲ-Ⅳa stage nasopharyngeal carcinoma

Abstract

Objective:To compare the near and long term efficacy and safety of paclitaxel(TAX) plus cisplatin(DDP) (TP regimen) and DDP plus 5-FU(PF regimen) concurrently combined with IMRT in treatment of patients with advanced NPC.Method: A retrospective analysis on 108 advanced NPC cases from January 2010 to December 2012 was conducted. The patients were divided into TP group(57 cases) and PF group(51 cases) according to therapy regimen. TP group received IMRT combined with TP therapy, and PF group received IMRT combined with PF regimen, two groups were both used 4 cycles of chemotherapy, toxicity reactions during concurrent radiochemotherapy were noted. Two months after treatment, near clinical efficacies of the two groups were determined, and then, a three years followingup was conducted, during which recurrence ratio, metastasis ratio, local control ratio and survival rate were analyzed. Result: Two months after treatment, the total effective ratio of TP group(84.2% vs.76.5%) was higher than PF group,however, the difference was not statistically significant(P>0.05). Gastrointestinal reaction(70.2% vs.66.7%), marrow inhibition(75.4% vs.82.4%), liver function damage(12.3% vs.13.7%), radioactive oral and pharyngeal injury(91.2% vs.98.0%)， hearing damage(15.8% vs.15.7%) in the two groups during chemoradiotherapy had no significant differences(P>0.05). During followingup, the recurrence and metastasis ratio in TP group(33.3% vs.47.1%) was lower than PF group(χ²=2.116,P=0.146). TP group with The local control rate(73.7% vs.68.5%) and survival rate(84.2% vs.78.4%) after three years treatment in TP group were higher than PF group(χ²=0.336,P=0.562；χ²=0.596,P=0.440). Conclusion: IMRT concurrently combined with TP and PF respectively are both effective methods for treatment of advanced NPC. In this study, IMPT plus TP concurrent chemoradiotherapy has a certain superiority in near and long term clinical treatment efficacy and safety.