Retina–electrode interface properties and vision restoration by two generations of retinal prostheses in one patient—one in each eye

Abstract

Objective. The Argus I implant is a first-generation epiretinal prosthesis approved for an investigational clinical trial in the U.S. Its successor, the Argus II implant, has a higher electrode density for increased spatial resolution and covers a larger retinal area to accommodate a wider visual angle. Both generations of Argus restored some vision to end-stage RP patients, but it remains unclear how the increased electrode count affected the visual percepts. Here we report a study of the first person on earth with two ‘bionic eyes’, with an Argus I implanted in one eye and Argus II in the other, to compare the retina–electrode interface and the visual outcome of the two devices. Approach. The retina–electrode interface was examined by electrode impedance, perceptual threshold, and ophthalmic images such as ocular coherence tomography data and fundus imaging. The subject’s visual outcomes were evaluated by computer-based visual function tests and subjective feedback. Main results. The electrode impedance of both Argus I and II slowly decreased overtime after implantation, accompanied by a gradual increase in the perceptual threshold. A quantitative analysis of the impedance and retina–electrode distance revealed somewhat different causes of impedance change in Argus I vs. II. Evaluation of the visual functions restored and feedback from the subject suggest that the Argus II device enables improved spatial visual ability over Argus I, but adaptation to prosthetic vision did not lead to a measurable performance improvement in the standard visual function tests. Significance. This study of Argus I and II in the same subject directly compares for the first time the interface properties and prosthetic vision in two eyes that share the same disease mechanism and converged visual pathway in higher visual centers, offering exciting new insights into the influence of the electrode parameters and layout to prosthetic vision.Trial registration: Data collected within clinical trials registered at NIH (NCT00279500 & NCT01860092).