Results of a Prospective Cohort Study on Open Rives Technique of the Midline Incisional Hernia: Midline Closure and Mesh Overlap

Abstract

Background. Rives repair has been traditionally used for large abdominal wall defects with good results on terms of recurrence. However, it is limited by the lateral border of the posterior rectus sheath. The objective of our study was to evaluate recurrence rate, midline closure and mesh overlap in patients operated on elective midline incisional hernia by open Rives retromuscular repair. Methods. This is a prospective observational study of 83 patients who underwent elective open Rives technique between January 2014 and December 2018. Main inclusion criteria were adults with a midline incisional hernia. Recurrence, midline closure and mesh overlap were determined. Results. At a median postoperative follow-up of 32 (5-59) months, 8 cases of recurrence were reported. Patients with recurrence had wider hernia defects (101 ± 52mm vs 66 ± 36mm, P = .014) and were repaired with wider meshes (191 ± 93mm vs 137 ± 68mm, P = .042). However, although it was not statistically significant, midline closure was lower (38% vs 59%), as well as the overlapping relationship between mesh area and hernia defect area (2.937:1 vs 3.732:1) on patients that developed a recurrence. Conclusions. Rives technique provides good mid-term results in a midline incisional hernia (10% of recurrence at 36 months), including wider hernias in the recurrent cohort. The authors believe that other techniques which allow midline closure and placement of bigger meshes should be considered, especially in those hernias classified as W3 on EuraHS classification (more than 10cm on width size).