Response to nebulizaed ipratropium bromide and terbutaline in acute severe asthma

Abstract

Outpatient studies on asthmatics have shown that inhaled anti-cholinergic agents decrease in efficacy as FEV1 falls. To determine whether there are changes in response to inhaled anti-cholinergics during acute bronchoconstriction we have examined the effects of nebulized ipratropium and terbutaline in nine hospitalized patients recovering from acute severe asthma. At 6 a.m. each day throughout the admission, baseline PEFR was recorded. Ipratropium bromide, 1 mg, was nebulized and PEFR measured again 1 h later. Following this, terbutaline, 5 mg, was nebulized with further measurement of PEFR 15 min after nebulization. Results were analysed by paired t-tests. Mean baseline PEFR rose from 157 l m-1 on patients worst day to 300 l m-1 on their best day (P less than 0.01). Ipratropium improved mean PEFR by 55 l m-1 and 42 l m-1 on patients worst and best days respectively (P less than 0.01). Subsequent terbutaline improved mean PEFR on patients worst day by 23 l m-1 (P less than 0.01) but only by a non-significant 4 l m-1 on their best day (P = 0.09). Hence, ipratropium produced 96% of total bronchodilatation when baseline was highest, but achieved only 71% of total response when baseline was lowest, a highly significant change in response (P less than 0.01). We conclude that in acute severe asthma as baseline PEFR rises response to inhaled ipratropium improves, compared with total response to combined ipratropium followed by terbutaline.