Response surface methodology-based optimisation of cost and compressive strength of rubberised concrete incorporating burnt clay brick powder

Abstract

Modified concrete is increasingly being produced by substituting concrete constituents with waste materials. Among waste materials are powder from waste clay bricks replacing Ordinary Portland Cement and Waste Tire Rubber (WTR) replacing natural coarse aggregate. However, the use of modified concrete is controlled by its cost-performance balance. This paper investigates the cost advantages of using rubberised concrete incorporated with Burnt Clay Brick Powder (BCBP) where findings are evaluated in comparison with conventional concrete. In this study, compressive strength of rubberised concrete containing BCBP was investigated using mixes generated by Response Surface Methodology (RSM). Central Composite Design (CCD) based on RSM was used to assess the influence of replacement variables of BCBP (0–5%) and WTR (0–20%) on concrete production cost and concrete compressive strength responses. First order and second order mathematical models were developed by RSM with findings from experimental design. The accuracy of the mathematical models established by CCD was tested using Analysis of Variance (ANOVA). Desirability analysis was then employed to optimise BCBP and WTR contents yielding maximum compressive strength at lower cost. Moreover, under the established optimum conditions, the performance of the optimum independent variables was experimentally verified by testing 6 cubes. Production cost of concrete containing these waste materials reduced up to 4.23% compared to conventional concrete. RSM evaluation demonstrated that the empirical findings were well suited into linear and quadratic models for cost and compressive strength responses respectively. The coefficients of determination of greater than 0.85 for all responses established that the models were capable of explaining variability in the responses. 5% BCBP and 6.875% WTR were optimum contents establishing maximum 7-days compressive strength of 27.607 MPa at lower cost of KSh 13 718.43. Optimisation of cost and 28-days compressive strength from desirability analysis gave 5% BCBP and 5.844% WTR contents as optimum values. This optimum combination resulted to maximum compressive strength of 33.970 MPa and lower cost of KSh 13 734.64. Verification of the model findings indicated considerable agreement with the verified values. From the findings, it was confirmed that a reasonable cost-performance balance for modified concrete can be achieved using BCBP and WTR.