Reproducibility of navigation based kinematic analysis of the knee – A cadaveric investigation

Abstract

PurposeSeveral navigation-based kinematic studies of the knee have been published recently, but little information is available about reproducibility and reliability of the acquired data. The aim of the present study first is to determine reproducibility and reliability of kinematical measurements of healthy knees and knees after TKA (total knee arthroplasty) with regards to rotational and translational measurement parameters. Second the mathematical background, applicability, and limitations of investigating navigation-based kinematics should be compiled. MethodsUsing cadavers fixed by the Thiel method, in ten knees reproducibility of obtained angular and translational kinematic parameters were investigated before and after total knee arthroplasty. For this reason agreement of obtained data of a first and a second movement cycle and the same after a surgical intervention was assessed using a commercially available navigational device. ResultsFor both angular and translational parameters in healthy knees and knees after total knee arthroplasty mean differences between measured parameters of the first and second movement cycle and after surgical intervention of less than 0.5° or millimeters (standard deviation 1.3 or less) or a inter class correlation of 0.92 and more, respectively, was found. DiscussionUse of a commercial navigation system allows highly accurate investigations of knee kinematics in cadavers before and after TKA. This technique, which does not require any specific technical knowledge of the investigator, is in accordance with current accepted biomechanical methods.