Repeating the Race Experience: John Dewey and the History Curriculum at the University of Chicago Laboratory School

Abstract

Despite the vast literature on Dewey and his laboratory school, most scholars have failed to contextualize Dewey’s pedagogical ideas in the intellectual currents of the period, particularly the historicist concept of social development known as recapitulation and/or correspondence theory. In this article, the author explores how and why history was taught at Dewey’s laboratory school at the University of Chicago (1896–1904). To do so, the author traces how Dewey’s approach to teaching history not only emerged out of pedagogical disputes, but also out of 19th-century historicist theories of evolutionary anthropology and genetic psychology. From this context, the author argues that Dewey’s history curriculum was based entirely upon his own interpretation of the anthropological-sociological-psychological theory of recapitulation, which suggested that the stages of child development corresponded with the development of Western civilization. Drawing on Dewey’s professional correspondence, course syllabi, and book reviews in addition to his published essays, the author suggests that this ethnocentric theory of recapitulation served as the foundation for the entire curriculum at the laboratory school, guiding both theory and practice.