Repeatability and Accuracy of the Pressed Juice Percentage Method at Sorting Steaks into Juiciness Categories

Abstract

The objective of this study was to evaluate the repeatability of the Pressed Juice Percentage (PJP) as well as to determine the accuracy of previously determined PJP thresholds at sorting beef strip loin steaks into categories based on the probability of being rated juicy by sensory panelists. Beef strip loin steaks representing 3 USDA quality grades (Prime, Low Choice, and Low Select) and Low Select strip loin steaks enhanced to 108% of the raw weight with a water, salt, and alkaline phosphate solution were cooked to three degrees of doneness [DOD; Rare (60°C), Medium (71°C), Very Well-Done (82°C)] to maximize variation in juiciness. Paired steaks were evaluated for PJP, Slice Shear Force (SSF), and Warner-Bratzler shear force (WBSF). Additionally, steaks representing Prime, Low Choice, and Low Select that were non-enhanced or enhanced with the same enhancement solution cooked to three DOD [Rare (60°C), Medium (71°C), Very Well-Done (82°C)] from a previously conducted sensory study were used to evaluate the ability of PJP to sort steaks into juiciness categories. Results indicated PJP had a high repeatability coefficient of 0.70, indicating only a small portion (30%) of the variation observed was due to sample measurement differences between paired samples. The repeatability of SSF and WBSF were 0.68 and 0.85, respectively. The evaluated PJP threshold values accurately segregated strip loin steaks by the probability of a sample being rated as juicy (mean juiciness rating of > 50) by consumers. The actual percentage of juicy samples was determined to be 41.67, 72.31, 89.33, and 98.08% for the predicted < 50%, 50 to 75%, 75 to 90%, and > 90% categories, respectively. Results of this study indicate the PJP juiciness measure is both repeatable and accurate in sorting beef strip loin steaks based on the likelihood of a steak being classified as juicy by consumers.