Relative biological effectiveness of photon energies used in brachytherapy and intraoperative radiotherapy techniques for two breast cancer cell lines

Abstract

Background. Partial breast irradiation (IORT or brachytherapy) differ from external radiation of whole breast in terms of irradiated volumes, fractionation, radiation energy and dose rate; all factors influencing the treatment outcome in a complex manner. Theoretically obtained RBE values comparing effects of radiation used in IORT and external therapy are published, but experimental studies are required to confirm these data. The aim of this study is to establish such RBE values for two breast cancer cell lines. Materials and methods. Colony formation of breast cancer cell lines (MCF-7 and T-47D) were studied after photon irradiation with qualities and dose rates used in IORT, brachytherapy and external radiation. RBE values from survival data were used to compare effects. Results. Increasing the photon energy (dose rate 0.2 Gy/min) from 50 kV (Intrabeam) to 380 keV (192Ir source) and 6 MV (linear accelerator) yielded an increase in the cell survival, whereas increasing the dose rate to 6 Gy/min had minor effect. Average RBE values for 50 kV with 6 MV as reference radiation varied from about 1.4 (for doses < 5 Gy) to > 1.9 (for doses < 0.02 Gy) for MCF-7 cells and from about 1.4 to > 3.1 for T-47D cells for the same dose levels. Corresponding RBE values for 380 keV radiation were about 1.4 for MCF-7 cells and 1.3–2.3 for T-47D cells. Conclusion. RBE data for breast cancer cells exposed to radiation used in IORT, brachytherapy or external radiation differ among the cell lines tested. The values are in agreement with published theoretical and experimental work.