Relationships among growth, δ13C, foliar nitrogen concentration, foliar nitrogen content and intercepted radiation at different cultural intensities, planting densities and site indices reveal the importance of water use efficiency in mid-rotation loblolly pine stands

Abstract

Carbon isotope composition (δ13C), intercepted photosynthetically active radiation (IPAR), foliar nitrogen (N) content and foliar N concentration are all factors related to stand growth and productivity. The relationships between these attributes and growth were studied in 15 and 16-year-old loblolly pine (Pinus teada L.) stands at planting densities ranging from 1483 to 4448 tree ha−1 grown under two silvicultural management intensities, both having different fertilization inputs. Measurements were conducted on six sites in the lower and upper coastal plains of Florida, Georgia and Alabama at site indices (SI) (base age 25 years) ranging from 18.6 to 29.6 m. The effects of planting density, cultural intensity and SI on the aforementioned attributes were studied. Correlations between δ13C, foliar N concentration, foliar N content, IPAR and current annual increment (CAI) of stem volume, stem wood biomass, branch biomass, foliage biomass and total above-ground biomass were also studied. We hypothesized that foliar N would be a better predictor of growth than either δ13C or IPAR, and that IPAR would be the same across planting densities due to canopy closure.The results indicated that CAI of stem volume, stem wood biomass and total above-ground biomass were affected by SI or the interaction between SI and management intensity. The significant relationships between SI and CAI growth indices were all positive indicating greater growth at greater site indices. A negative correlation was found between δ13C, a surrogate for water use efficiency, and SI, meaning stands had lower water use efficiencies at sites with higher SI values. Foliar N concentration and content were both affected by silvicultural intensity, while IPAR was only affected by planting density. Among the physiological parameters, δ13C was the only parameter significantly correlated with the CAI indices. Significant negative correlations were found between CAI of stem volume, stem wood biomass, total above-ground biomass and δ13C. These results indicated that moisture availability affected growth of the highly fertilized mature stands in this study. The findings reported here, when compared to similar studies in younger stands, suggest that growth limitations shifted from light availability to soil moisture availability in older stands when nitrogen was not limiting.