Relationship of habitat stability and intra-specific population dynamics of an obligate corallivore butterflyfish

Abstract

1. Intra-specific behavioural manifestations, as measured by territory size and conspecific agonistic encounters, population size and recruitment of the obligate corallivore butterflyfish Chaetodon multicinctus (Family: Chaetodontidae) were examined over a 5-year period at three Hawaiian coral reef sites, each receiving different levels of non-point-source terrigenous sediment runoff. 2. All three sites indicated significant correlations for percentage coral cover with territory size, fish size, and number of adult C. multicinctus, and for agonistic encounters with number of juvenile C. multicinctus. However, the site most impacted by sediment runoff indicated no significant correlations for percentage coral cover with territory size, fish length, number of adult C. multicinctus, number of agonistic encounters, or C. multicinctus juveniles; nor for number of agonistic encounters with number of juveniles. 3. The site moderately to minimally impacted by sediment runoff exhibited significant correlations for percentage coral cover with number of adults, while the site with no sedimentation impacts exhibited significant correlations for percentage coral cover with fish size, number of adults and number of juveniles. 4. Significant differences were found to exist between all three sites for agonistic encounters, territory size, fish size, number of C. multicinctus juveniles and percentage coral cover. The most highly impacted site exhibited a significantly higher number of adult C. multicinctus that were significantly smaller in size than either the minimally impacted and non-impacted sites. 5. The study design purposely selected high coral cover habitats (means ranged from 81.4% to 96.5%) at each site. Within this limited range of relatively high coral cover habitat, relative habitat stability resulting from a range of historic sediment inputs between sites appears to be the stronger forcing function for observed intra-specific behavioural manifestations, population size and recruitment than percentage coral cover. 6. Study results indicate that obligate corallivore butterflyfish behavioural manifestations, population size and recruitment may be used as a benchmark for changes in habitat stability for coral reef communities, and support the general premise of the butterflyfish indicator species hypothesis. Copyright © 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.