Relationship between dental caries experience of a group of Japanese kindergarten children and the results of two caries activity tests conducted on their saliva and dental plaque

Abstract

To establish a dental caries preventive programme in 4- and 5-year-old children, caries activity tests were used to assess salivary levels of mutans streptococci (using the Mucount test, Showa Yakuhin, Japan) and the acidogenic ability of dental plaque bacteria (using the Cariostat test, Sankin, Japan) in 260 kindergarten children. The relationships between the results of these two tests and the dental caries experience (dfs) of the children was evaluated. There was a significant positive correlation between the results of the Mucount and Cariostat tests in the total group of subjects. However, 91 subjects (35%) gave conflicting results with the two tests. These subjects were divided into two groups: one group (group B) included Mucount-negative and Cariostat-positive subjects, and the other group (group C) included Mucount-positive and Cariostat-negative subjects. Group B had a significantly higher mean dfs score than a group that was negative on both tests (group A). On the other hand, no significant difference in mean dfs score was observed between group C and group A. These findings suggested that mutans streptococci levels alone are an insufficient indicator for assessing dental caries activity of children at these ages and that the role of lactobacilli and other aciduric bacteria should be considered. It was concluded that assessment of caries activity using both Mucount and Cariostat tests is useful for a dental caries preventive programme for children of these ages.