Relationship between agricultural pesticides and the diet of riparian spiders in the field

Nadin Graf,Katharina Frisch,Ralf B Schäfer,Jochen P Zubrod,Martin H Entling,Verena C Schreiner,Andreas Scharmüller,Mirela Cimpean,Moritz Link,Karina P Battes,Eduard Szöcs

doi:10.1186/s12302-019-0282-1

Nadin Graf, Katharina Frisch + Show 9 more

Open Access

https://doi.org/10.1186/s12302-019-0282-1

Copy DOI

Abstract

BackgroundExamining the effects of pesticides is difficult in regions such as Western Europe because of the relatively ubiquitous use of agrochemicals and the lack of unaffected areas. To study a wide gradient of agrochemical stress, we conducted a study in Central Romania, where traditional agriculture, which is assumed to use less agrochemicals, exists adjacent to intensive agriculture. We investigated potential effects of land use related stressors including pesticides on aquatic–terrestrial predator–prey relationships using stable isotope analysis. Therefore, we sampled spiders, as well as their aquatic and terrestrial prey along streams with a pesticide pollution gradient and determined spider and prey stable carbon and nitrogen signals.ResultsAquatic prey contributed 40.8–55.4% to the diet of the orb web weaving spider Tetragnatha sp. and 34.0–53.0% to the diet of the ground-hunting Pardosa sp. The biomass of potential aquatic prey increased along a gradient of increasing riparian habitat conditions and water quality and decreasing agriculture (e.g. arable land) in the catchment. The proportion of aquatic prey in the orb web weavers diet responded positively to the biomass of potential aquatic prey and negatively to this gradient. Increasing potential prey biomass resulted in an increasing proportion of aquatic prey for the orb web weaver. The proportion of aquatic prey in the ground hunters diet increased with in-stream pesticide toxicity and along a gradient of increasing pastoralism in the catchment as well as increasing riparian habitat and water quality.ConclusionThe diet of two riparian predators responded to complex gradients of catchment land use, stream and riparian habitat quality as well as to in-stream pesticide toxicity. The responses to the different environmental variables can be attributed to direct (e.g. change in spider community) and indirect (e.g. changes in aquatic prey and terrestrial prey) effects. Future manipulative field studies or experiments on aquatic–terrestrial food webs are required to examine the causality of our findings and should also consider the quality of prey organisms to foster mechanistic understanding of cross-ecosystem effects.

Highlights

Examining the effects of pesticides is difficult in regions such as Western Europe because of the relatively ubiquitous use of agrochemicals and the lack of unaffected areas
We found that changes in riparian spider communities correlated with in-stream pesticide toxicity [23]
To rigorously test hypotheses related to underlying mechanisms, we suggest that future studies on the response of spiders to agricultural land use and pesticide gradients should consider i) potential direct effects on abundances and ii) potential indirect effects resulting from direct effects on aquatic and terrestrial prey availability

Summary

Introduction

Examining the effects of pesticides is difficult in regions such as Western Europe because of the relatively ubiquitous use of agrochemicals and the lack of unaffected areas. We investigated potential effects of land use related stressors including pesticides on aquatic–terrestrial predator–prey relationships using stable isotope analysis. We sampled spiders, as well as their aquatic and terrestrial prey along streams with a pesticide pollution gradient and determined spider and prey stable carbon and nitrogen signals. Graf et al Environ Sci Eur (2020) 32:1 emergence through changes in land use may subsequently affect the diet of terrestrial predators and in turn components of the terrestrial food web. Several studies showed that environmental conditions including stressors alter insect emergence from streams and in turn the diet of riparian predators (e.g. birds) consuming aquatic prey [4, 11, 14]. Land use related stressors can affect the aquatic–terrestrial coupling with effects propagating into terrestrial food webs. Metal pollution reduced aquatic prey availability and in turn density, composition and abundance of riparian spiders [16, 18]

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion