Reference change values to assess changes in concentrations of biomarkers of exposure in individuals participating in a cigarette-switching study

Abstract

In a previous clinical study, levels of biomarkers of exposure (BoEs) for specific toxicants were significantly reduced in smokers who switched from conventional cigarettes to reduced toxicant prototype (RTP) cigarettes. Very little is known about the biological variability of tobacco smoke BoEs within individuals and sub-groups, and the descriptive group-comparison statistics might not be sufficient to understand such changes. Therefore, we assessed how different statistical methods could be used to interpret changes in urine BoE levels at the individual level. We used non-parametric statistical reference limits, the empirical rule and reference change values (RCVs) to assess changes in levels of BoEs related to four toxicants in cigarettes smoke. Current smokers [of 6 mg and 1 mg International Organization for Standardization (ISO) tar yields] were allocated to switching to RTP groups or non-switching control groups within their respective tar bands. There were two 6 mg tar study groups, with a non-switching group (CC6, n=46) and a group switching to an RTP containing tobacco-substitute sheet and modified filter (TSS6, n=49); and three 1 mg tar smoker groups, with one non-switching (CC1, n=42), a group switching to an RTP containing tobacco-substitute sheet and modified filter (TSS1, n=44) and one switching to an RTP containing an enzyme-treated tobacco and modified filter (BT1, n=47). Assessment of the direction of change showed that up to the 100% of subjects experienced a decrease in levels of some BoEs. Between 49% and 64% of subjects in the switching groups were classified as having decreased levels of 3-hydroxy-1-methylpropylmercapturic acid (HMPMA) by the non-parametric criterion, whereas only 2%-6% had reduced levels of N-nitrosoanatabine (NAT). Of non-switchers, in 7%-14% of those smoking 1 mg ISO tar yield cigarettes increases were classified across all BoEs. RCVs highlighted patterns with more detail, showing that most changes occurred within 14 days of switching. Among smokers who switched to 6 mg RTPs, 40%, 44%, 6% and 15%, respectively, were classified as experiencing significant decreasing levels of HPMA, 3-hydroxypropylmercapturic acid, 4-(methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanol and NAT, whereas in the two 1 mg switching groups 46%, 22%, 11% and 52% and 43%, 27%, 2% and 16% had decreased levels of the same biomarkers. Up to five subjects in the 6 mg non-switching group were classified as having increased levels of all BoEs. Although we believe that is not possible to determine whether the observed changes in BoEs reflect biological relevance, the use of reference values enables assessment of changes in BoEs at the individual level. Estimates of the BoE variability between subjects might aid study design and setting minimum targets for smoke toxicant yields for future development of RTPs.