Reduction in Unindicated Cervical Cancer Screening in Adolescents in a Large Health Care System.

Abstract

Evidence-based guidelines recommend against screening for cervical cancer (Pap testing) in average-risk adolescents <21 years old. Despite this, many still undergo unindicated screenings with subsequent detrimental reproductive health and economic consequences. Our aim was to reduce unindicated cervical cancer screening in individuals <21 years old in a large health care system by utilizing an electronic provider notification. Starting in July 2020, a Best Practice Advisory (BPA) appeared in the electronic medical record (EMR) if providers ordered Pap testing on individuals <21 years old. This BPA reiterated that screening was not indicated for average-risk adolescents and prompted users to choose an indication if they wanted to proceed.A retrospective chart review, pre/post intervention study was performed comparing individuals <21 years old with Pap testing performed before and after intervention (January 2019-June 2020 and July 2020-June 2021, respectively). Patient characteristics were extracted from the EMR and analyzed using Fisher exact tests, Kruskal-Wallis tests, and logistic regression. There were 140 subjects included: 106 preintervention and 34 postintervention. There were no differences in baseline characteristics. Neither Pap nor human papillomavirus testing results differed between the groups. Preintervention, 6.6% of cytology tests were indicated compared to 20.6% postintervention ( p = .042). The proportion of indicated human papillomavirus testing did not differ preintervention and postintervention at 65% and 45%, respectively ( p = .295). The overall reduction in unindicated cervical cancer screening postintervention was 13.9% (95% CI = 4.0-23.7). We demonstrated that incorporating a BPA to the EMR reduces unindicated cervical cancer screening.