Recommendation of using both initial pupil size and constriction latency in pupillary light reflex as objective indicators reflecting subacute pain-related mental fatigue

Abstract

A previous study examining clinical subacute pain models under different methodological conditions showed that pain-induced mental fatigue can be associated with decreased initial pupil size (INIT)/shortened constriction latency (LAT) in the pupillary light reflex (PLR). We aimed to investigate the potential of INIT/LAT as objective indicators reflecting mental fatigue under the same methodological conditions. We recruited 118 patients planning to undergo three types of representative otolaryngological head and neck surgery procedures. We used the numerical rating scale (NRS) to assess subjective pain intensity and two mental fatigue-related mood categories of the Profile of Mood States, as well as INIT and LAT measurements (1) in the afternoon one day before surgery (pre1-surgery), (2) in the morning of the day of surgery (pre2-surgery), and (3) in the morning of the day following surgery (post-surgery). We assessed time point-dependent changes using one- or two-way analysis of variance, as well as responses of PLR parameters to mental fatigue using linear mixed-effects models (LMMs). As a result, NRS scores, the two mood categories, as well as LAT and INIT, showed significant time point-dependent changes. In post-hoc analyses, only INIT showed significant changes between the two pre-surgery time points. Thus, INIT values fluctuated even under pain-free conditions due to differences in the time of the day. LMMs demonstrated decreased INIT/shortened LAT related to mental fatigue. All surgical groups showed similar associations between mental fatigue and INIT/LAT findings. As each parameter has advantages and disadvantages, it is recommended to use both INIT and LAT as the indicators.