Recolonization of estuarine organisms: effects of microcosm size and pesticides

Abstract

Two six-week laboratory experiments were conducted to evaluate effects of pesticides and microcosm size on benthic estuarine macroinvertebrate recolonization. Sediments fortified with the pesticides (fenvalerate: controls, 5 (low) and 50 µg g−1 wet sediment (high); endosulfan: controls, 1 (low) and 10 µg g−1 wet sediment (high)) were fine-grained, organically rich (approximately 3.5% organic carbon and 22% dry weight) material. Relative dominance of the four most abundant taxa in both experiments was consistent among treatments with few exceptions. The amphipod,Corophium acherusicum, dominated abundance in both experiments. In the fenvalerate experiment, large trays (400 cm2) contained significantly (p<0.05) more total number of taxa (TNT) than small microcosms (144 cm2) but tray size was not significantly related to total number of organisms (TNO). When size was adjusted to a common unit area, small trays contained significantly more TNO than large containers. Adjusted abundance of small trays was 2.5 times that of large containers; a ratio close to that of microcosm sizes (i.e., 2.8). This result suggests that larval supply may have been inadequate to ‘aturate’ the available sediment in large containers. Fenvalerate significantly reduced abundance in the high treatment compared to both controls and low treatment but low treatment was not significantly different from controls. The amphipod,Corophium acherusicum, accounted for most of the decrease in abundance in response to fenvalerate. The holothruroid,Leptosynpta sp. and the polychaete,Mediomastus ambiseta, increased in abundance significantly with increased concentration of fenvalerate. Combined effects of actual microcosm size and concentration of endosulfan were not significant for TNO or TNT. As in the fenvalerate experiment, adjusted abundance of small microcosms was 2.6 times that of large trays which approximated the ratio of unit area between microcosm sizes. Abundance of a few taxa responded significantly to adjusted and unadjusted unit area. Abundance of the tunicate,Molgula manhattensis, increased significantly with increased concentration of endosulfan. Abundance was affected by sample location (e.g., interiorvs exterior cores) within microcosms. Abundance adjusted to unit area resulted in significantly greater TNO in externalvs internal cores. This has importance for sequential sub-sampling of microcosms to determine temporal dynamics. Statistically significant effects were measured in benthic community structure associated with microcosm size; however, the magnitude was relatively small. There appears to be no major biological reason to select one microcosm size over the other for screening for contaminant effects. Where feasible, the small trays provide savings in sample preparation and analysis, allow more replicates where laboratory space is limiting and generate less chemical waste. These benefits may be off-set by less ‘artifacts’ associated with edge effects of larger microcosms and the need for a larger mass of sediment to accommodate additional analytical requirements (e.g., thin vertical surficial samples to refine contaminant exposure at the sediment/water interface).