Realistic Performance Characterization of CFD Applications on Intel Many Integrated Core Architecture

Abstract

This paper studies the performance characteristics of computational fluid dynamics (CFD) applications on Intel Many Integrated Core (MIC) architecture. Three CFD applications, BT-MZ, LM3D and HOSTA, are evaluated on Intel Knights Corner (KNC) coprocessor, the first public MIC product. The results show that the pure OpenMP scalability of these applications is not sufficient to utilize the potential of a KNC coprocessor. While utilizing the hybrid MPI/OpenMP programming model helps to improve the parallel scalability, the maximum parallel speedup relative to a single thread is still not satisfactory. The OpenCL version of BT-MZ performs better than the OpenMP version but is not comparable to the MPI version and the hybrid MPI/OpenMP version. At the micro-architecture level, while the three CFD applications achieve reasonable instruction execution rates and L1 data cache hit rates, use a large percent of vector instructions, they have low arithmetic density, incur very high branch misprediction rates and do not utilize the Vector Processing Unit efficiently. As a result, they achieve very low single thread floating-point efficiency. For these applications to attain competitive performance on the MIC architecture as on the Xeon processors, both the parallel scalability and the single thread performance should be improved, which is a difficult task.