Real Competition and Profit Rate Equalisation: Theory and Evidence from the Norwegian Economy

Abstract

The existence of long-run profitability differentials in market economies is a fundamental question that all traditions of economic thought since the times of the classical economists have dealt with in some form or another. In consideration of the modern synthesis of the classical views on competition into what has come to be known as the Theory of Real Competition, this article presents both a consistent theoretical basis from which to argue in favour of the tendential elimination of profitability premia across industries, as well as empirical evidence pointing to such conclusion from the Norwegian economy. The data, which covers 26 industries across nearly five decades (1971–2017), is used to estimate average and incremental total long-run profit rate differentials following two distinct methodologies. The first method has been commonly used in the prior literature, and the second has been newly systematised by this study’s author. Both methods are critically scrutinised, and their results compared to allow for a more robust conclusion. The findings suggest that average profit rates exhibit a weak tendency towards equalisation in Norway, and that such tendency is much stronger for incremental profit rates.