Reaction mechanisms on liquid and solid acid catalysts. Correlation with acidity

Abstract

The probe bases used for measurement of strength of acid catalysts need to be structurally similar to the catalytic substrates. Traditional acidity measurements are inapplicable when the hydron transfer forms a tight ion pair, as on solid acids. Also, solid acids are much weaker than liquid acids of similar structure. Alkane activation by C–H and C–C cleavage, evidenced in strong superacids, does not occur in less strongly acidic media. The reactivity patterns and structure–reactivity relationships are the same for the cationoidic species (weakly coordinated carbocations) occurring in the less strong acids as for the full-fledged carbocations intervening in superacids. Even in trifluoromethanesulfonic acid, a weak superacid, the first step in alkane activation is an oxidation, forming unsaturated carbocations. On sulfated zirconia, the first step of alkane reactions is a one-electron oxidation. Mechanistic features incompatible with standard (or “traditional”) carbocationic processes, are observed in the reaction of 3-methylpentane on the zeolite HZSM-5.