REACH and reproductive and developmental toxicology: still questions

Abstract

Registration, Evaluation, Authorization, and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) is a new chemicals regulation law in the European Union (EU). The law is supplemented by tens of thousands of pages of guidance documents, and the implementation of REACH is still a work in progress. Requirements for chemical testing are based on the annual volume of a chemical or ‘substance’ that is produced or imported into the EU. These requirements include reproductive and developmental toxicity testing in experimental animals for an annual volume of 10 metric tonnes or more. However, under REACH, the testing in vertebrate animals may not be performed without permission, and the law encourages the use of alternative methods of filling data gaps on the toxicological properties of chemicals. These alternatives might include in vitro and structure-activity relationship studies, but the REACH technical guidance indicates that these kinds of studies are not adequate to replace reproductive and developmental toxicity testing in whole animals. The most practical opportunity for the avoidance of whole animal testing may be ‘read-across,’ a process in which gaps are filled using data from related compounds. A method called ‘weight of evidence’ under REACH may also be used to avoid whole animal reproductive and developmental toxicity testing based on existing data in regulation and non-regulation studies and based on factors such as chemical structure and anticipated exposure. It is also possible that thresholds of toxicological concerns will be accepted under REACH as a method to avoid vertebrate animal testing.