Re-evaluation of the penicillamine challenge test in the diagnosis of Wilson’s disease in children

Abstract

A urinary copper (Cu) >25 micromol/24 h following penicillamine had a reported specificity of 98.2% and sensitivity of 88.2% in diagnosing Wilson's disease (WD). We have re-evaluated this test. Ninety-eight subjects were studied at presentation. Thirty-eight (19 girls, 19 boys; median age 10.3 years; range 5-16 years) had an ultimate diagnosis of WD. Sixty (24 girls, 36 boys; median age 10.1, range 2.3-15 years) had other liver disorders. Urinary Cu was estimated for 24h before (basal Cu) and for 24h whilst giving penicillamine 500 mg orally 12 hourly x 2 (post-penicillamine Cu). Both basal Cu and post-penicillamine Cu differed significantly between WD patients and controls (basal Cu: median 6.5 micromol/24 h, range 0.9-109 micromol/24 h, versus median: 0.8 micromol/24 h, range 0.1-19.5, p<0.0001; post-penicillamine Cu: median 36.9 micromol/24 h, range 1.98-219 micromol/24 h, versus median 12.35 micromol/24 h, range 0.5-49.8 micromol/24 h, p<0.0001). A post-penicillamine Cu >25 micromol/24 h was observed in 29/38 patients with WD and in 4/60 controls. 25/38 WD patients were symptomatic. Twenty-three of these and 6/13 asymptomatic siblings had a positive test. The test had a sensitivity of 76% (95% confidence interval [CI], 59.8-88.6%) and a specificity of 93% (95% CI, 83.8-98.2%). Sensitivity was better in symptomatic patients (92%, [95% CI; 74-99%]) than asymptomatic (46%, [95% CI; 19.2-74.9%]). This test is valuable in the diagnosis of WD with active liver disease, but is unreliable to exclude the diagnosis in asymptomatic siblings.