Rate theory of gas-liquid nucleation: Quest for the elusive quantitative accuracy.

Abstract

The task of a first principles theoretical calculation of the rate of gas-liquid nucleation has remained largely incomplete despite the existence of reliable results from unbiased simulation studies at large supersaturation. Although the classical nucleation theory formulated by Becker-Doring-Zeldovich about a century ago provides an elegant, widely used picture of nucleation in a first-order phase transition, the theory finds difficulties in predicting the rate accurately, especially in the case of gas-to-liquid nucleation. Here, we use a multiple-order parameter description to construct the nucleation free energy surface needed to calculate the nucleation rate. A multidimensional non-Markovian (MDNM) rate theory formulation that generalizes Langer's well-known nucleation theory by using the Grote-Hynes MDNM treatment is used to obtain the rate of barrier crossing. We find good agreement of the theory with the rate obtained by direct unbiased molecular dynamics simulations-the latter is feasible at large supersaturation, S. The theory gives an experimentally strong dependence of the rate of nucleation on supersaturation, S. Interestingly, we find a strong influence of the frequency-dependent friction coefficient at the barrier top. This arises from multiple recrossings of the barrier surface. We find that a Markovian theory, such as Langer's formulation, fails to capture the rate quantitatively. In addition, the multidimensional transition state theory expression performs poorly, revealing the underlying role of the friction coefficient.