Radiotherapy for stage 2 testicular seminoma: the prognostic influence of tumor bulk.

Abstract

Forty-nine consecutive patients with stage 2 testicular seminoma were treated with primary radiotherapy from 1968 to 1985. Overall diseases-free survival (DFS) for patients with 36 months minimum follow-up was 82% at 3 years. This figure did not decline further with time. Infradiaphragmatic bulk disease was found to be a significant prognostic factor for local and distant relapse as well as for ultimate survival. Patients with either stage 2A or 2B disease (infradiaphragmatic bulk less than or equal to 10 cm size) had a 3-year DFS of 89% compared with a 64% 3-year DFS rate for patients with stage 2C disease (infradiaphragmatic bulk greater than or equal to 10 cm size). The (local plus distant) relapse rate was 4.0% for patients with stage 2A disease, 16.7% for patients with stage 2B disease, and 33.3% for patients with stage 2C disease. The majority of distant relapses were multifocal and prophylactic mediastinal irradiation did not appear to influence either relapse rate nor overall survival. Of seven patients who relapsed, four died of progressive malignancy, two deaths were related to salvage chemotherapy, and only one patient is alive and well following successful chemotherapeutic salvage. On the basis of our experience, we recommend radiotherapy with the use of modern imaging techniques as initial treatment for patients with retroperitoneal masses less than 10 cm size. Aggressive cisplatin-based chemotherapy should be seriously considered for patients with retroperitoneal masses greater than or equal to 10 cm size, or for patients who relapse following radiotherapy.