Radiosensitivity of new and established human melanoma cell lines: Comparison of [ 3H]thymidine incorporation and soft agar clonogenic assays

Abstract

Seven new low-passage melanoma lines were developed in this laboratory from clinical melanoma specimens and characterised for chromosome complement, DNA ploidy and S-phase content. The radiosensitivity of these lines was compared with that of eight established melanoma cell lines, FME, MM-96, SK-MEL-5, SK-MEL-28, SK-MEL-2, MALME-3M, M19-MEL and LOX-IMVI, using a 96-well microculture assay technique. Dose-response curves were determined using a 5-day incubation period and 6-h terminal [ 3H]thymidine-labelling period. Radiation ( 60Co source) was carried out under a lead wedge to provide a radiation dose range of 0–10 Gy, or by irradiating part of the plate (radiation dose 0 or 2 Gy). Data for a range of cell densities in a single 96-well plate were combined into a single regression equation incorporating linear quadratic terms for radiation dose and cell density. SF 2 values were defined as the amount of thymidine incorporated following a radiation dose of 2 Gy, expressed as a fraction of that of unirradiated cells, and varied from 0.36 to 0.93. The reproducibility in repeat assays, as defined by the standard error of determinations at different passage numbers, was ±0.04. The newly developed lines exhibited a similar range of radiosensitivity to that of the established lines, and melanin content did not correlate with resistance. For nine of the lines, radiation parameters were also determined using a modified Courtenay clonogenic soft agar assay technique, and the results compared with the thymidine incorporation results, and a significant linear correlation was found between SF 2 and SF 2′ ( r = 0.89). The linear (α) and quadratic (β) terms of the best-fit linear quadratic dose-response curves, were significantly correlated between the two assays. It is concluded for this series of human melanoma lines that proliferation assays in 96-well plates provide radiosensitivity parameters comparable to those using clonogenic assays.