Radiation of mushroom-forming fungi correlates with novel modes of protecting sexual fruiting bodies

Abstract

The protection of vulnerable developing structures evolved repeatedly in terrestrial organisms and includes, among others, viviparity in animals and the seed in land plants. In mushroom-forming fungi (Agaricomycetes), sexual spores are born on fruiting bodies, the growth of which is a complex developmental process that is exposed to environmental factors (e.g., desiccation, fungivorous animals). Mushroom-forming fungi evolved a series of innovations in fruiting body protection, however, how these emerged is obscure, leaving the evolutionary principles of fruiting body development poorly known. Here, we show that developmental innovations that lead to the spore-producing surface (hymenophore) being enclosed in a protected environment display asymmetry in their evolution and are associated with increased diversification rates. ‘Enclosed’ development evolved convergently and became a dominant developmental type in several clades of mushrooms. This probably mirrors spore production benefits for species with protected fruiting body initials, by better coping with environmental factors. Our observations highlight new morphological traits associated with mushroom diversification that parallel the evolution of protection strategies in other organisms, such as viviparity or the seed in animals or plants, respectively, but in the context of spore development, highlighting the general importance of protecting vulnerable progeny across the tree of life.