Quaternary ammoniums and other preservatives’ contribution in oxidative stress and apoptosis on Chang conjunctival cells. Debbasch C, Brignole F, Pisella PJ, Warnet JM, Rat P, Baudouin C. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2001;42:642–652.

Abstract

The authors investigated some of the toxicity mechanisms in vitro of ten preservatives currently used in ophthalmic solutions. A continuous human conjunctival cell line was treated with different concentrations of various preservatives for 15 minutes and for 15 minutes followed by 24 hours of cell recovery: three benzalkonium chlorides (BACs) with different hydrocarbon chain length, benzododecinium bromide (BOB), cetrimide (Cet), phenylmercuric nitrate, thimerosal, methyl parahydroxybenzoate, chlorobutanol, and EDTA. An inhibition study was then conducted using a one-hour vitamin E pretreatment followed by a 15-minute BAC treatment. Membrane integrity was assessed using a neutral red test and chromatin condensation with a Hoechst 33342 test. Reactive oxygen species were measured using dichlorofluorescein diacetate test for H2O2 production and hydroethidine test for peroxide anion production. These tests were performed using microplate cold light cytofluorometry. Cell size and DNA content were also analyzed using flow cytometry. Confocal microscopy was used to explore morphologic changes. A significant decrease of membrane integrity with chromatin condensation was observed with all the quaternary ammoniums tested at concentrations of 0.005% and higher. The effect was amplified after 24 hours of cell recovery. The other preservatives tested did not decrease membrane integrity. H2O2 production was observed with all the preservatives, whereas peroxide anion production was significantly higher with the quaternary ammoniums at 0.005% and 0.01%, compared with the other preservatives. Flow cytometry results confirmed the cytotoxicity observed with cold light cytofluorometry. The authors conclude that the quaternary ammoniums tested (BAC, BOB, and Cet) were the most cytotoxic preservatives in the current model. An apoptotic mechanism appeared to be present at low concentrations of quaternary ammoniums, whereas a necrotic process appeared at higher concentrations. Superoxide anions may play an important role in tissue damage induced by preservatives in ocular surface disorders.—Thomas J. Liesegang