Quantum Gravity: third edition

Abstract

The request by Classical and Quantum Gravity to review the third edition of Claus Kiefer's 'Quantum Gravity' puts me in a slightly awkward position. This is a remarkably good book, which every person working in quantum gravity should have on the shelf. But in my opinion quantum gravity has undergone some dramatic advances in the last few years, of which the book makes no mention. Perhaps the omission only attests to the current vitality of the field, where progress is happening fast, but it is strange for me to review a thoughtful, knowledgeable and comprehensive book on my own field of research, which ignores what I myself consider the most interesting results to date.Kiefer's book is unique as a broad introduction and a reliable overview of quantum gravity. There are numerous books in the field which (often notwithstanding titles) focus on a single approach. There are also countless conference proceedings and article collections aiming to be encyclopaedic, but offering disorganized patchworks. Kiefer's book is a careful and thoughtful presentation of all aspects of the immense problem of quantum gravity. Kiefer is very learned, and brings together three rare qualities: he is pedagogical, he is capable of simplifying matter to the bones and capturing the essential, and he offers a serious and balanced evaluation of views and ideas. In a fractured field based on a major problem that does not yet have a solution, these qualities are precious. I recommend Kiefer's book to my students entering the field: to work in quantum gravity one needs a vast amount of technical knowledge as well as a grasp of different ideas, and Kiefer's book offers this with remarkable clarity. This novel third edition simplifies and improves the presentation of several topics, but also adds very valuable new material on quantum gravity phenomenology, loop quantum cosmology, asymptotic safety, Horava–Lifshitz gravity, analogue gravity, the holographic principle, and more. This is a testament to the wide-angle attention of Claus Kiefer to the recent evolution of the field.It is also because of this attention that the neglect of a thriving research direction on which a large number of research groups are currently engaged jumps to the eye. The book provides a nice introduction to loop quantum gravity. The main kinematical results of the loop approach are carefully explained. At the point of discussing dynamics, however, it focuses only on the canonical formulation, mentioning the covariant loop theory only en passant. Given Kiefer's open-mindness, I imagine that the shortfall is due to the novelty of the major results of the covariant theory (or spinfoam formalism). The theorem proving the finiteness of the transition amplitudes to all orders, due to Han, Fairbairn and Meusburger, for instance, dates only from 2010. But the various theorems on the asymptotic of the vertex amplitude, by Barrett–Pereira–Dowdall–Fairbairn–Hellmann, Friedel–Conrady and others, which have sparked interest in the spinfoam approach by indicating that the theory may have the correct classical limit, are from 2009. The fact that they are not even mentioned in Kiefer's book is strident for me. The covariant loop amplitudes may not be the final solution to the problem of quantum gravity, but the existence of a family of Lorentz covariant amplitudes with indications of the correct classical limit, which are finite at each order of the expansion, is a result that cannot be ignored in a broad book that aims at being comprehensive in quantum gravity.There are other pages of the book where I was not very happy. For instance, the discussion of the so-called 'problem of time'. But surely a broad book in a recalcitrant field like quantum gravity will never make everybody entirely happy: at least as long as the problem is not solved. Which, we all hope, might not be too far into the future. Few fundamental problems have resisted the investigation of theoretical physics for so long, and today advances are fast. So, here is my recommendation: study this book, complement it with what is missing, and help us in finally solving the extraordinarily beautiful problem of understanding quantum spacetime.