Quantity and quality of water percolating below the root zone of three biofuel feedstock crop systems

Abstract

Biofuel demand is on the rise, yet there is limited information available about the likely implications of increased planting of cellulosic biofuel crops on water and nutrient fluxes. To help address this gap, this study quantifies subsurface water, nitrate, and dissolved phosphorus fluxes below feedstock crops managed for biofuel production on naturally well drained soils in southern Wisconsin. Automated equilibrium tension lysimeters were used to measure subsurface (below root zone) fluxes of water and nutrients below continuous corn (CC), monoculture switchgrass (SG), and hybrid poplar (HP) cropping systems for three years. Average water fluxes below SG were nearly double those below CC and HP. Most of this difference can be linked to seasonal events, particularly during late winter and early spring when subsurface water fluxes and increased soil moisture were observed below SG plots, likely due to enhanced macropore flow. Nitrate fluxes were approximately 14 times higher below CC than the 37.4 kg NO3-N/ha three year annual average observed for SG; the nitrate fluxes were negligible below HP despite similar nitrogen application rates. The high flux in one of the two CC plots is likely due to excessive manure applications prior to the study period; however, the nitrate loss potential from CC is much higher than the perennial crops. Dissolved reactive phosphorus (DRP) concentrations were very low below all three cropping systems (average of 0.076, 0.083, 0.034 mg/L in SG, CC, and HP respectively). For the cropping systems evaluated, nitrate fluxes were driven by concentration differences in leachate and not influenced by nominal differences in N fertilizer inputs, whereas DRP fluxes were mainly driven by water fluxes and therefore independent of phosphorus inputs and soil test phosphorus. The data in this paper provide a foundation to better understand differences in fluxes below different biofuel cropping systems.