Quantitative Comparison of Heavy Metals and As Accumulation in Agricultural and Forest Soils near Bowling Green, Ohio

Abstract

Soil samples from agricultural and adjacent forest soils in Northwest Ohio were collected and analyzed for As, Cr, Cu, Ni, Pb, and Zn. pH, Eh, electrical conductivity, and moisture content were also measured. Selected samples were also evaluated for grain size and X-rayed to identify clay minerals. In this region, soils contain a large proportion of fines (∼32% clay and ∼37% silt) with illite, dickite, and chlorite as the main clay minerals. Surface soils in the arable land are slightly acidic (pH ∼5.6) while forest soils are near-neutral to slightly basic. All soils become more basic with depth. Soil Eh and electrical conductivity range from 300 to 450 mV and 100 to 375 μS, respectively. In the soil profiles, between 0 and 50 cm depth, As increases from 4.6 to 11 mg/kg, Cr increases from19 to 23 mg/kg and Ni increases 21 to 29 mg/kg. In contrast, Cu decreases from 23 to 17 mg/kg and Pb decreases from17 to 10 mg/kg. Surface enrichment of Cu and Pb can be the result of aerosol deposition, while the downward increase in As, Cr and Ni is related to pedogenic variation. The average concentration of Zn in the samples is 64 mg/kg and does not change with land-use or depth. With the exception of As, the concentration of metals in the agricultural soil is not significantly different from the concentration in forest soil. The concentration of As in the near-surface arable soil (5.6 mg/kg) is significantly different from the concentration of As in the near-surface forest soil (4.3 mg/kg). In both cases, deeper soils have similar As contents. The relative enrichment of As in the surface arable soil could indicate input from herbicides or pesticides. The upward increase in electrical conductivity is interpreted to show that the exchangeable fraction of each metal is higher in the surface soils. However, the near neutral pH and organic, clay-rich soils may limit the mobility. The concentration of these heavy metals and As in the soils are much lower than the limits set by the United States Environmental Protection Agency.