Quantifying the effects of contour tillage in controlling water erosion in China: A meta-analysis

Abstract

Contour tillage is a widely practiced conservation tillage in China. The beneficial effects of contour tillage in controlling water erosion have been recognized, further researches are needed to quantify the effectiveness of contour tillage in reducing water erosion and identify the influencing factors in China. We conducted a nationwide meta-analysis based on 229 runoff and 290 sediment paired observations from 47 published papers from national and international literatures. The results showed that compared to traditional tillage, the benefits of contour tillage in China with respect to runoff and sediment reduction were 35.86% and 49.02%, respectively. Sediment yield reduction by contour tillage was greater under simulated rainfall than under natural rainfall. Runoff reduction by contour tillage decreased with the increasing mean annual precipitation and temperature, while sediment yield reduction was not affected by climate factors. Contour tillage in loamy soils and soils with organic carbon content > 1% showed the greatest benefits in reducing sediment yield (64.26% and 52.52%, respectively). The greatest runoff and sediment yield reduction (61.04% and 67.24%, respectively) occurred at slope length > 20 m. The greatest runoff reduction by contour tillage was found for tillage duration > 10 years (44.08%), while the greatest sediment yield reduction occurred at tillage duration ≤ 5 years (52.89%). The effectiveness of contour tillage under cereals was better for runoff and sediment yield reduction compared to legumes and rotation as consequence of the high biomass quantity and lower mineralization rate of cereal straw. Our results conclude that contour tillage is an effective measure for controlling water erosion, and its benefits in reducing runoff and sediment yield are different according to the climate, soil properties, topography and management practices.