Abstract

The growth of private-equity investment strategies in which firms often hold partial ownership interests in competing firms has led competition agencies to take an increased interest in assessing the competitive effects of partial horizontal acquisitions. We propose a methodology to evaluate the coordinated effects of such acquisitions on differentiated products industries. The acquisitions may be direct and indirect, and may or not correspond to control. The methodology, that nests full mergers, evaluates the impact on the range of discount factors for which coordination can be sustained. We provide an empirical application to several acquisitions in the wet shaving industry.

Highlights

  • Full acquisitions complete and permanently eliminate competition among the ...rms involved in the transaction

  • The proposed empirical structural methodology can cope with acquisition settings involving all types of owners and ownership rights: owners that can be internal to the industry and external to the industry; and ownership rights that can involve ...nancial interests and corporate control, can be direct and indirect, can be partial or full

  • We provide an empirical application of the methodology to a variety of actual and hypothetical acquisitions in the wet shaving industry that give rise to cross- and common-ownership structures

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Full acquisitions complete and permanently eliminate competition among the ...rms involved in the transaction. 2004) in order to encompass real-world industry features, and are assumed to follow grim-trigger strategies, the most basic enforcement mechanism to sustain a coordinated arrangement (Friedman, 1971) This structural setting is used to simulate the counterfactual stream of operating pro...ts of ...rms under the di¤erent regimes of the tacit coordination model (Davis, 2006; Davis and Huse, 2010), which, in turn, are used to evaluate quantitatively the likelihood of coordinated conduct pre- and post-acquisition. The proposed empirical structural methodology can cope with acquisition settings involving all types of owners and ownership rights: owners that can be internal to the industry (rival ...rms) and external to the industry; and ownership rights that can involve ...nancial interests and corporate control, can be direct and indirect, can be partial or full.3 This structural approach to assess the coordinated e¤ects of partial horizontal acquisitions has not been, to our knowledge, examined in any other academic study. Structural methodology used to evaluate the coordinated e¤ects of partial horizontal acquisitions, Section 4 provides the above mentioned empirical application, and Section 5 concludes

Literature Review
The Setup
Cross-Ownership
Common-Ownership
Competitive Setting
Coordinated Behavior
Empirical Application
Data Description and Preliminary Analysis
Step 0
Consumer Flow Utility
Estimation Procedure
Consumer Demand Estimation Results
Step 1
Recover Unobserved Marginal Costs under Non-Cooperative Behavior
Recover Unobserved Marginal Costs under Coordinated Behavior
Identify the Competitive Setting of Firms in the Industry
Step 2
Counterfactual Equilibrium Prices
Non-Deviation Conditions
Minimum Discount Factor and Critical Threshold
Step 3
Conclusions
Weight Function of the Manager
Compute the Critical Threshold Pre-Acquisition
Compute the Critical Threshold Post-Acquisition
16. WS Ultra Glide Twin 5r
G Good News Pivot Plus 10r
Findings
G ASR PL WL WS preacquisition voting voting voting voting non voting

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.