Quantified acoustic–optical speech signal incongruity identifies cortical sites of audiovisual speech processing

Abstract

A fundamental question about human perception is how the speech perceiving brain combines auditory and visual phonetic stimulus information. We assumed that perceivers learn the normal relationship between acoustic and optical signals. We hypothesized that when the normal relationship is perturbed by mismatching the acoustic and optical signals, cortical areas responsible for audiovisual stimulus integration respond as a function of the magnitude of the mismatch. To test this hypothesis, in a previous study, we developed quantitative measures of acoustic–optical speech stimulus incongruity that correlate with perceptual measures. In the current study, we presented low incongruity (LI, matched), medium incongruity (MI, moderately mismatched), and high incongruity (HI, highly mismatched) audiovisual nonsense syllable stimuli during fMRI scanning. Perceptual responses differed as a function of the incongruity level, and BOLD measures were found to vary regionally and quantitatively with perceptual and quantitative incongruity levels. Each increase in the level of incongruity resulted in an increase in overall levels of cortical activity and in additional activations. However, the only cortical region that demonstrated differential sensitivity to the three stimulus incongruity levels (HI > MI > LI) was a subarea of the left supramarginal gyrus (SMG). The left SMG might support a fine-grained analysis of the relationship between audiovisual phonetic input in comparison with stored knowledge, as hypothesized here. The methods here show that quantitative manipulation of stimulus incongruity is a new and powerful tool for disclosing the system that processes audiovisual speech stimuli.