Qualitative Qualities, Meaningful Measurements?

Abstract

Many academics appear to have lost interest in the critique of practices and subjectivities in the neoliberal university. In this article, we insist on the value of keeping the critical debate on the neoliberal university alive, in spite of competition, individualization, and silence. We aim to contribute to the debate with thoughts about the ways in which “quality” is construed and measured in the evaluation practices that consume an increasingly large amount of academics’ time. In a process that began with preparations for a panel at the first European Congress of Qualitative Inquiry in 2017, we use collaborative writing as a method of inquiry to explore how the use of “quality” criteria is performative in dynamics of inclusion and exclusion that inscribe us as subjects within neoliberal discourse in the audit culture. Finally, we argue that such reflexive exploration is important in order to cultivate meaningful pockets of critical, collaborative research and teaching practices.