Quadriceps force in relation of intrinsic anteroposterior stability of TKA design

Abstract

Decreased quadriceps strength and fatigue is suspected to be one of the contributing factors for anterior knee pain and malfunction after total knee arthroplasty (TKA). The purpose of this in vitro study was to investigate the amount of quadriceps force required to extend the knee isokinetically after TKA in dependence of different prosthesis designs and the state of the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL). Eight fresh frozen human knee specimens underwent testing in a kinematic device simulating an isokinetic knee extension cycle from 120° of flexion to full extension. The quadriceps force was measured after implantation of a cruciate retaining (CR) TKA (Genesis II, Smith&Nephew, Memphis, TN, USA) applying a conventional CR (11 mm) and a highly conforming (deep dished, DD) polyethylene (PE) inlay consecutively before and after resection of the PCL. Finally, tests were repeated with a posterior-stabilized (PS) design. Simulating a physiological knee extension, no significant differences in the average quadriceps force were detected between the cruciate preserving inlays (CR 1,146.57 ± 88.04 N, DD 1,150.19 ± 97.54 N, P = 0.86) as long as the PCL was intact. After resection of the PCL, the required quadriceps force increased significantly for both designs (CR 1,203.17 ± 91.51 N, P < 0.01 and DD 1,191.88 ± 80.07 N, P < 0.03). After implantation of the posterior stabilized femoral component quad force decreased to its initial levels with forces significantly lower compared to the PCL deficient knees provided with a CR or DD (PS 1,130.91 ± 107.88 N, P < 0.01) inlay. With a deficient PCL there were no statistical differences for the DD design in comparison with CR in mean quad forces (CR 1,203.17 ± 91.51 N vs. DD 1,191.88 ± 80.07 N, P = 0.50) nor in peak forces (CR 1,729.44 ± 161.86 N, DD 1,688.66 ± 123.18 N, P = 0.17). At intact PCL peak quad forces and mean forces beyond 70° of flexion could be shown to be significantly lower with a PS TKA design in comparison with cruciate preserving designs such as CR and DD. In the PCL deficient knee quad forces with a highly conforming implant (DD) and CR were significantly higher than with a PS TKA. The use of PS implants in all PCL deficient knees seems to be advisable