Public history and the fragments of place: archaeology, history and heritage site development in southern Alberta

Abstract

The recent call for heritage professionals to consider the ‘spirit of place’ is an attempt to reconcile the overlapping layers of tangible and intangible heritage within significant sites. However, the desire for wholeness can also displace the fragments and fragmented histories of place. This paper examines the history of heritage development in southern Alberta through two sites, namely Head-Smashed-In Buffalo Jump (a designated UNESCO World Heritage Site) and Writing-on-Stone Provincial Park / Áísínai'pi National Historic Site (UNESCO World Heritage nomination currently being developed). Located only 200 km apart, these two places offer very different perspectives on the ‘spirit of place’ and present very different histories of the production of ‘heritage’ through archaeological excavation, preservation practices and Aboriginal consultation. These stories from the Canadian prairies raise questions about the processes of ‘place-making’, ‘place-taking’ and how we mobilize and conceptualize the practice of place in public history.