Prospective Outcome Analysis of the Safety and Efficacy of Partial and Complete Cryoablation in Organ-confined Prostate Cancer

Abstract

To determine the rate of complications and change in International Prostate Symptom Score and Sexual Health Inventory for Men scores following cryotherapy treatment of low- and intermediate-risk prostate cancer. The secondary end points were the change in prostate-specific antigen post cryotherapy and biopsy-proven recurrence. Enrollment occurred from 2007 to 2015 to assess long-term complications of cryotherapy. A prostate biopsy was performed at 1 year or in the event of biochemical failure. Subjects were staged and graded by standard 12- to 14-core transrectal ultrasound (TRUS) biopsy. A subset of subjects underwent additional 3-dimensional mapping biopsy if the cancer was suspected to be downgraded. Analyses of functional outcomes were stratified into focal and nonfocal treatments. The study consisted of 393 men with low- and intermediate-risk prostate cancer, aged 44-89 years. Patient IPSS scores improved significantly in the nonfocal treatment strata at all time points and after 1 year in the focal strata with a median drop at 1 year of 4 points (P <.001). No significant difference was detected for a change in preprocedural SHIM score in either treatment strata after 2 years (P >.7). Eighty-two patients (20.9%) had a rise in prostate-specific antigen resulting in biochemical failure. Seventy patients had detected recurrence for an overall recurrence rate of 20.4% in 343 patients. A total of 109 patients (27.7%) reported urinary retention and urgency post cryotherapy, with 15.3% requiring catheterization for up to 3 weeks. Thirty-seven patients (9.4%) experienced urethral meatal stricture, and 36 patients (9.2%) reported unresolved new-onset erectile dysfunction. Complication rates, most significantly erectile dysfunction, are decreased in this study compared with those previously reported in the literature for cryotherapy for prostate cancer.