Properness Without Elementaricity

Abstract

We present reasons for developing a theory of forcing notions which satisfy the properness demand for countable models which are not neces- sarily elementary sub-models of some (H(χ), ∈). This leads to forcing notions which are reasonably definable. We present two specific properties mate- rializing this intuition: nep (non-elementary properness) and snep (Souslin non-elementary properness) and also the older Souslin proper. For this we consider candidates (countable models to which the definition applies). A ma- jor theme here is by iteration, but we also show a dichotomy: if such forcing notions preserve the positiveness of the set of old reals for some naturally defined c.c.c. ideal, then they preserve the positiveness of any old positive set hence preservation by composition of two follows. Last but not least, we prove that (among such forcing notions) the only one commuting with Cohen is Cohen itself; in other words, any other such forcing notion make the set of old reals to a meager set. In the end we present some open problems in this area.