Promoting men's health through sports clubs: a rapid realist review

Abstract

Abstract Background Traditional health promotion interventions have failed to engage men. Sports clubs offer male-friendly health promotion settings for men, but little is known about implementable intervention strategies and subsequent effects. This rapid realist review (RRR) aims to identify context, mechanisms and effects of health promotion interventions targeting men by or in collaboration with sports clubs. Methods The RRR methodology was developed in collaboration with a panel of Danish practice and policy representatives and international academics. A systematic literature search was conducted in February 2023 for studies published after 2013 in MEDLINE, Embase, and SportDiscus databases and through grey literature sources. Included studies: 1) targeted men aged 18+ years, 2) reported health promotion outcomes, and 3) were delivered primarily by or in collaboration with sports clubs. Results Fifty-two studies were included. Preliminary analyses indicate that interventions delivered through sports clubs show promise for engaging men with high cardiometabolic risk and producing favorable health outcomes. Preliminary findings from the realist synthesis show that if men felt a strong attachment to the sports club (context), it resonated with their feelings of social identity which outweighed a former reluctance to attend health programs (mechanism), and thus increased the men's likelihood for program engagement and health behavior change (outcome). Conclusions Our study indicates that men's health promotion through sports clubs is emergent. While great strides have been made to increase men's involvement in health promoting activities by delivering interventions through sports clubs, research has predominantly focused on select behaviours (e.g., physical activity), sub-groups (e.g., sports fans) and predominantly Caucasian, overweight, middle-aged men.