Progressive expansion of seafloor anoxia in the Middle to Late Ordovician Yangtze Sea: Implications for concurrent decline of invertebrate diversity

Abstract

The Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event (GOBE) achieved its peak during the Middle Ordovician, likely in association with climatic cooling and a rise of atmospheric O2. However, unstable redox states developed widely in contemporaneous epeiric seas, challenging previous assumptions about sustained oceanic oxygenation driven by deep-ocean ventilation in the aftermath of Ordovician cooling. Here, we investigate two Middle-Upper Ordovician shale-dominated successions from intra-shelf basin and slope settings of the Yangtze Sea, South China. Negative shifts in bulk δ15N and productivity proxies reveal temporal changes in the pattern of nutrient cycling under moderate-to-high productivity conditions, which were likely sustained by increased upwelling of cold and nutrient-rich deep waters in sync with contemporaneous climatic cooling. As a result, marine anoxia likely expanded in deep waters of the Yangtze Sea, as reflected in enrichments of highly reactive iron and redox-sensitive metals (Mo, U). Although moderate Mo abundances (25-50 ppm) and δ98/95Mo values (+0.4 to +0.8‰) within the euxinic interval suggest that bottom waters had low sulfide concentrations, the δ98/95Mo values are comparable with those of coeval euxinic facies (∼+0.6‰). Furthermore, our modeling results show that low δ98/95Mo can be produced when sulfidic sinks dominate Mo removal, suggesting that Middle-Late Ordovician oceans may have been less oxygenated than previously assumed, at least for the continental seas of South China, Baltica and Laurentia. These environmental changes may provide a new explanation for the ∼50% decline of invertebrate species following the peak of GOBE. Our findings thus link the progressive expansion of marine anoxia and climatic cooling to a profound biotic change during the Mid-Late Ordovician Period.